I am not sure where this post is coming from. Just some random thoughts, I guess, and your mileage may vary.
A friend of mine, who is Catholic, and for whom I have tons of respect, and I have spoke a few times regarding "praying for the dead", which is a concept that is a little interesting and different to me. To refresh my memory, I looked here for the idea and concept of praying for the dead. I guess the idea is, and please correct me if I am wrong, while souls are in purgatory, they suffer purgatorial pain (whatever that might be) and that prayers and alms and other things on their behalf by the faithful living eases those pains. The link above remarks only on those who are penitent, and they suffer the pains if they have passed away before they have made satisfaction of their sins by penance.
So I wonder about those that are NOT penitent when they die. Are their pains more pronounced? Do they even go to purgatory? Or is there some other place for them? What of them who are not Catholic?
In contrast, the LDS point of view specifies a Spirit World, where all the souls of them who have passed on go to. The Spirit World is divided into two parts - Spirit Paradise, and Spirit Prison. These names are somewhat confusing, because those in Paradise teach those that are in Prison. So, in a sense, those that were faithful here on the earth go on to teach those who were never taught, for whatever reason, here on earth about the gospel. In the Spirit World, all still have their free agency, and can choose to accept or reject the gospel. Not all is revealed, so faith still plays a strong part in learning. Part of the problem with this is that it is much harder to school ones body to the yearnings of the spirit if the spirit and body are still separated. I suppose there could be pain and anguish upon learning and accepting the gospel in the spirit world that those spirits in prison might regret their deeds and missed opportunities. I also think that this may true for those in paradise as well - at least to a certain degree.
So I guess that when Latter-Day Saints pray for the dead, we pray that they will accept the gospel. If they had already accepted the gospel, we pray that they will be able to perform their calling to the best of their ability. For those that have not accepted the gospel on this earth, in time we can perform those gospel ordinances that they did not participate in while on the earth for them, under certain circumstances. Also, the idea of death to LDS is not such a dark one, but it is just merely the next transition. While the death of a loved one opens a void in our lives and hearts, that sorrow is mixed with the idea that a loving Father in Heaven has a plan for them, and we hope and pray that they will follow that plan. If they don't, then they don't. I am sure the Celestial Kingdom will be full of many families that have members missing from their ranks because of their choices.
So I guess I just wanted to compare and contrast. There is a lot I don't understand about the Catholic faith, and I am not trying to say which is right or wrong - you readers can decide that. I was just thinking these things, and didn't know how to pull them out.
I do pray for India, Thom, and all of you who have been touched by the events surrounding her death.
